Cheese Tasting: Prairie Sunset by Roth ||| Dégustation de Fromage : Prairie Sunset. By Vero Kherian on misscheesemonger.com.

Cheese Tasting: Prairie Sunset by Roth ||| Dégustation de Fromage : Prairie Sunset

Note: I received free product to write this post. All opinions are my own.

Happy Monday! It’s been hot in San Francisco, lately, like actual t-shirt and shorts weather! This never happens! M. Cheesemonger and I spent the entire weekend outside to mark the occasion. We saw so many previously hidden tattoos everywhere (not on me, though!)!

San Francisco sunshine! from food blogger and photographer Vero Kherian, misscheesemonger.com.
Hello, sunshine! ||| Bonjour, soleil !

This week on the blog, I want to share with you a new-ish cheese that’s been on my radar since January: Prairie Sunset by Roth in Wisconsin. People have asked me what it’s like, but really, it’s an original. It’s not like traditional gouda, not made like cheddar, not like jack . . . it is Prairie Sunset.

Glorious! ||| Glorieux ! Cheese Tasting: Prairie Sunset by Roth ||| Dégustation de Fromage : Prairie Sunset. By Vero Kherian on misscheesemonger.com.
Glorious! ||| Glorieux !

The cheese is intended to evoke the colors and spirit of the American Midwest. The cheesemakers at Roth wanted a cheese that is friendly, approachable, yet memorable and a star in its own right. They decided to color the cheese a rich, flaming orange with annatto, a traditional food coloring derived from the achiote tree, to evoke the sunset of the Midwestern prairie (hence the name!).

Cheese Tasting: Prairie Sunset by Roth ||| Dégustation de Fromage : Prairie Sunset. By Vero Kherian on misscheesemonger.com.
What color! ||| Quelle couleur !

Story aside, I wanted to know how it tasted. Many times, when a cheese is presented as approachable, that means dull or one-dimensional. I was really hoping that wasn’t the case here. Luckily, the cheese I met was rather complex, even if the over-all flavors were rather mellow. First off, it’s a beauty to behold—its glowing orange color was pretty showstopping alone. I loved the tiny eyes throughout the paste, creating a cheesy lace I have since been adding to pasta dishes. It smelled very mild, evocative of almonds and . . . . chocolate nibs. Tasting it was a treat: the mouthfeel on this current wheel (I’ve tasted several wedges over the months) was soft and slightly springy, yet somehow still on the flinty side. The flavor was nuttier than prior wedges I had tried (my previous piece had more of a cream top yogurt flavor). There was a slight sweetness at the finish reminding me of toffee.

Cheese Tasting: Prairie Sunset by Roth ||| Dégustation de Fromage : Prairie Sunset. By Vero Kherian on misscheesemonger.com.
Cheese, slightly abstract. ||| Du fromage, un peu abstrait.

When it came to pairing, well, I brought this cheese to my Tcho Chocolate visit, and we found a great accompaniment in their “Chocolatey” chocolate. The chocolate has a deep, deep roasted, almost coffee flavor, very far back on the finish, without a lot of brightness up front. Together with the cheese, it felt as though the chocolate created a solid floor of flavor on which the cheese could shine. And indeed, when I tasted them together, the cheese suddenly became brighter and tangier atop the “Chocolatey” square. It’s always so extraordinary seeing what new flavor combinations will bring. I did try a variety of jams, but everything seemed too sweet. This cheese really needs to be paired with umami—try it with your burgers or ultra dark chocolates!

Tcho Chocolate with Prairie Sunset. ||| Du chocolate Tcho avec Prairie Sunset. Cheese Tasting: Prairie Sunset by Roth ||| Dégustation de Fromage : Prairie Sunset. By Vero Kherian on misscheesemonger.com.
Tcho Chocolate with Prairie Sunset. ||| Du chocolate Tcho avec Prairie Sunset.

You can find Prairie Sunset at your local specialty cheese shop—if they don’t have it and you want to try it, ask them to carry it!

Blood oranges. ||| Des oranges sanguines. Cheese Tasting: Prairie Sunset by Roth ||| Dégustation de Fromage : Prairie Sunset. By Vero Kherian on misscheesemonger.com.
Blood oranges. ||| Des oranges sanguines.

Have you tasted this cheese? What do you think? Let me know in the comments below!

THANK YOU, Roth, for sending me a couple wedges of cheese for this post.

2nd Note: Can you do me a HUGE favor and take this survey? I’m looking for feedback on how to improve the blog!


It’s my work to create great content for you. Do you love what you see? Here is how you can support me:

HIRE ME! Let me bring your food projects, business, and products to life. Image may not be everything, but a great one sure helps—Let’s create something beautiful together! See my food photography portfolio. Or see my portrait portfolio for portrait and candid lifestyle work. Contact me to start brainstorming!

BUY through my affiliate account links at Amazon.com (where you can get nearly anything under the sun), the French Farm (where you can find delicious and beautiful French products for the kitchen, and get free shipping for orders over $75), and Taza Chocolate (maker of some of my favorite Mexican-style chocolates). Bookmark these links for later! You can purchase anything through them, not just what I recommend to you, and I will receive a small percentage of those sales at no extra cost to you! Everybody wins!